- all organisms have the potential of reproducing exponentially
- what is preventing organisms from reproducing at their potential?
- resources are limited
- organisms with better access to resources will be more successful in their reproductive efforts
- who gets better access to these limited resources?
Darwin could not of developed his theory without the help of Malthus he even said:
"In October 1838, that is, fifteen months after I had begun my systematic inquiry, I happened to read for amusement Malthus on Population, and being well prepared to appreciate the struggle for existence which everywhere goes on from long- continued observation of the habits of animals and plants, it at once struck me that under these circumstances favourable variations would tend to be preserved, and unfavourable ones to be destroyed. The results of this would be the formation of a new species. Here, then I had at last got a theory by which to work".-Charles Darwin, from his autobiography. (1876)
Darwin's basis for his entire theory was on the fact that traits are passed on and are changed by surroundings and a need for adaption. Which is what Malthus provides, explanation on why a human population grows and expands or withers and dies based on resources available.
Why it took Darwin so long to publish his work was because at the time it was extremely controversial and the church would not accept it, many still don't. But he feared that going against the status quo would result in threats or the fate Galileo suffered. And the result of his publication was many people ignored it and chose not to believe and but it is now out there and is widely accepted.
Sites
http://members.optusnet.com.au/exponentialist/Malthus_Evolution.htm
http://www.ucmp.berkeley.edu/history/malthus.html
Great post, I enjoyed reading the information you presented. It is amazing how some people still don't or won't believe in evolution. Even with all of the science and studies to back it up. It proves how influential and strong the Church still is even in this day and time.
ReplyDeleteYour post is amazing. I had a hard time choosing between the different choices but you did a wonderful job pointing out the differences and similarities between Darwin and Charles Malthus. Great job!!
ReplyDeleteGreat post, good points all around especially the use of Darwin himself to support your contention that Malthus was pivotal to his work.
ReplyDeleteGood background on Malthus work and, in general, good selection of bullet points. I do have a quibble with the last two bullet points. Malthus certainly raised the point of limited resources and its impact on human populations. The points of how limited resources impacted reproductive efforts and the question of who gets those limited resources are natural extensions of Mathus' ideas but they were raised by Darwin, not Malthus. Malthus actually didn't recognize that limited resources would reduce reproduction. He was actually concerned with overpopulation of humanity. He saw that the natural world seemed to have a natural check on non-human populations and despaired at its apparent absence in human populations.
ReplyDeleteGreat quote. Darwin himself recognized just how significant Malthus was to his work.
During Darwin's time, there was not really a fear of imprisonment by the Church of England, as happened with Galileo, but the Church could still make a person's life difficult if they weren't happy with your words or actions. Your position in a community could be threatened, loss of status, etc. Darwin also was worried about the impact on his wife, who was very religious. How would she feel if he published a paper that could be interpreted as an attack on the church?
Good post.
I agree with your post. Thomas Malthus had a huge impact on Charles Darwin's theory of Natural Selection. I think you did a good job overall on the assignment!
ReplyDeleteI think you did a great job on you blog post. By far one of my favorite. You were informative. I Really like how you quoted Darwin on Malthus.
ReplyDelete-Naomi
Your blog post was very well done, I also do like how you quoted Darwin about Malthus instead of only a quote from Malthus. This shows that you actually spent some time researching. As for the constructive part, i think you could include a quote in the beginning that supports the claims of what Malthus' research stated. Overall great job!
ReplyDeleteGreat job. I also thought Malthus was an influential person on Darwin as well. The information that you produced was more than evident that Darwin couldn't have it done it without Malthus. Keep up the awesome work !
ReplyDelete